{"case_id":"113年度金訴字第51號","case_number":"113年度金訴字第51號","chunk_filename":"chunk_0026.txt","chunk_index":26,"documents_referenced":["120284號文（相關回復文件）","處理人民陳情事項注意事項","都發局簽呈"],"end_seconds":7970,"keywords":["京華城","圖利罪","對外效力","行政規則","都委會","都發局","陳情研議"],"legal_issues":["行政行為是否具備對外效力","行政規則（注意事項）是否構成圖利罪中之「法令」","被告之主觀動機是否為圖利京華城"],"legal_issues_raw":["行政規則（注意事項）是否構成圖利罪中之「法令」","行政行為是否具備對外效力","被告之主觀動機是否為圖利京華城"],"participants":["嚴邦論","林洲民","林清聰","楊智鎮","辯方律師"],"participants_raw":["辯方律師","林清聰","林洲民","嚴邦論","楊智鎮"],"phase":"言詞辯論","record_type":"segment","segment_id":"7SD1Ue5QAiE:chunk_0026","session_date":"2025-12-19","session_id":"7SD1Ue5QAiE","session_part":"下午","start_seconds":7670,"summary":"辯方針對本案之爭點進行陳述。首先主張「處理人民陳情事項注意事項」僅為內部業務處理方式，不屬於圖利罪定義中的「法令」，且相關人員對其內容並不熟悉，不存在對外效力。其次，針對檢方指稱之「護航京華城」動機，辯方說明都發局建議將爭議移至都委會討論，係為了讓京華城透過公開透明程序表達意見，並將爭議移轉至決策機關（都委會）處理，而非意圖護航。","video_id":"7SD1Ue5QAiE","raw_text_key":"text/7SD1Ue5QAiE/raw/chunk_0026.txt","cleaned_text_key":"text/7SD1Ue5QAiE/cleaned/chunk_0026.txt","_links":{"self":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/7SD1Ue5QAiE:chunk_0026","read":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/7SD1Ue5QAiE:chunk_0026/read","raw":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/7SD1Ue5QAiE:chunk_0026/raw","cleaned":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/7SD1Ue5QAiE:chunk_0026/cleaned","session":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/sessions/7SD1Ue5QAiE","case":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/cases/113年度金訴字第51號"}}