{"case_id":"113年度金訴字第51號","case_number":"113年度金訴字第51號","chunk_filename":"chunk_0024.txt","chunk_index":24,"documents_referenced":["南港西部計畫案申請資料","南港輪胎西部計畫案申請資料","圖管條例","大法官釋字第七十二號","都市計畫法","都市計畫細部計畫書"],"end_seconds":7380,"keywords":["容積獎勵","法規性質","細部計畫","行政處分","都市計畫法","釋字第七十二號","雙軌制"],"legal_issues":["大法官釋字第七十二號關於都市計畫法規性質之解釋","容積獎勵之給予標準與行政處分之救濟","都市計畫之「雙軌制」土地使用管制之適用","都市計畫細部計畫是否具有法規性質"],"legal_issues_raw":["都市計畫之「雙軌制」土地使用管制之適用","都市計畫細部計畫是否具有法規性質","容積獎勵之給予標準與行政處分之救濟","大法官釋字第七十二號關於都市計畫法規性質之解釋"],"participants":["丁玉群","林清龍","檢察官","發言人（律師或代理人）"],"participants_raw":["發言人（律師或代理人）","林清龍（證人/公務員）","丁玉群（前都發局局長，文中提及）","檢察官（文中提及）"],"phase":"言詞辯論","record_type":"segment","segment_id":"IB49wmaJWtw:chunk_0024","session_date":"2025-12-16","session_id":"IB49wmaJWtw","session_part":"下午","start_seconds":7080,"summary":"本段逐字稿主要討論都市計畫中「雙軌制」的執行方式，以及細部計畫是否具有法規性質並能給予容積獎勵。發言者引用臺北市政府前都發局長丁玉群的觀點及大法官釋字第七十二號，主張細部計畫屬法規性質之命令，應可據以給予容積獎勵。同時，發言者質疑證人林清龍在庭上表示不可給予獎勵，但其主持之實際案例（如南港西部計畫案、南港輪胎案）卻均給予容積獎勵，存在矛盾。","video_id":"IB49wmaJWtw","raw_text_key":"text/IB49wmaJWtw/raw/chunk_0024.txt","cleaned_text_key":"text/IB49wmaJWtw/cleaned/chunk_0024.txt","_links":{"self":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/IB49wmaJWtw:chunk_0024","read":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/IB49wmaJWtw:chunk_0024/read","raw":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/IB49wmaJWtw:chunk_0024/raw","cleaned":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/IB49wmaJWtw:chunk_0024/cleaned","session":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/sessions/IB49wmaJWtw","case":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/cases/113年度金訴字第51號"}}