{"case_id":"113年度金訴字第51號","case_number":"113年度金訴字第51號","chunk_filename":"chunk_0014.txt","chunk_index":14,"documents_referenced":["105年度監察院糾正案","109年10月12日專家會議紀錄","檢方補充留書","行政程序法（平等原則）","起訴書","都市更新條例","都市計畫法第24條"],"end_seconds":4430,"keywords":["圖利罪","監察院糾正案","自提細部計畫","行政裁量","都市更新","都市計畫法","防禦權"],"legal_issues":["圖利罪中「違背法令」之範圍界定與擴張","監察院糾正案對公務員行政行為之拘束力","行政裁量權是否受司法過度介入","都市計畫法第24條關於自提細部計畫之適用與獎勵限制","都市計畫變更與都市更新條例之區分（準用與適用之爭議）"],"legal_issues_raw":["圖利罪中「違背法令」之範圍界定與擴張","都市計畫法第24條關於自提細部計畫之適用與獎勵限制","都市計畫變更與都市更新條例之區分（準用與適用之爭議）","行政裁量權是否受司法過度介入","監察院糾正案對公務員行政行為之拘束力"],"participants":["劉玉山","林欽榮","白仁德","蔣官","辯護律師","邵琇珮","黃景茂"],"participants_raw":["辯護律師","蔣官（檢察官/法官）","林欽榮（證人）","邵琇珮（證人/公務員）","黃景茂（證人）","劉玉山（專家/委員）","白仁德（專家/委員）"],"phase":"言詞辯論","record_type":"segment","segment_id":"NDpqyQ8TlV0:chunk_0014","session_date":"2025-12-17","session_id":"NDpqyQ8TlV0","session_part":"上午","start_seconds":4130,"summary":"辯護律師針對圖利罪之違法定義、都市計畫法第24條之適用、以及監察院105年糾正案對行政程序之影響進行辯論。律師主張檢方（長官）在證人作證後擴大解釋「違背法令」之範圍，損害被告防禦權，並強調本案屬都市計畫變更而非都市更新，且都發局之處理係基於監察院糾正案之要求，不應被認定為違法圖利。","video_id":"NDpqyQ8TlV0","raw_text_key":"text/NDpqyQ8TlV0/raw/chunk_0014.txt","cleaned_text_key":"text/NDpqyQ8TlV0/cleaned/chunk_0014.txt","_links":{"self":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/NDpqyQ8TlV0:chunk_0014","read":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/NDpqyQ8TlV0:chunk_0014/read","raw":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/NDpqyQ8TlV0:chunk_0014/raw","cleaned":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/NDpqyQ8TlV0:chunk_0014/cleaned","session":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/sessions/NDpqyQ8TlV0","case":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/cases/113年度金訴字第51號"}}