{"case_id":"113年度金訴字第51號","case_number":"113年度金訴字第51號","chunk_filename":"chunk_0012.txt","chunk_index":12,"documents_referenced":["營建署99年6月17日會議紀錄","都市計畫施行自治條例第7條","都更容獎辦法","都計法第24條","京華城案件之第一版草案及修訂說明"],"end_seconds":3840,"keywords":["京華城","公展程序","圖利","容積獎勵","對價性","都市計畫","都更","類推適用"],"legal_issues":["公務員在已知有釋法疑慮之情況下，仍指示送審是否構成圖利","容積獎勵之對價性審查缺失","是否違反都市計畫施行自治條例第7條（審查是否不當或有礙公共利益）","非都更地區是否能類推適用都更容積獎勵之合法性"],"legal_issues_raw":["是否違反都市計畫施行自治條例第7條（審查是否不當或有礙公共利益）","非都更地區是否能類推適用都更容積獎勵之合法性","公務員在已知有釋法疑慮之情況下，仍指示送審是否構成圖利","容積獎勵之對價性審查缺失"],"participants":["公務員","專家學者","應","林中明","邵琇珮","都市設計科人員（顏邦瑞、張家綺）","黃景茂"],"participants_raw":["黃景茂（都發局長）","邵琇珮","應議員","林中明","都市設計科人員（顏邦瑞、張家綺）","專家學者","公務員"],"phase":"言詞辯論","record_type":"segment","segment_id":"NfrdKX5NBQc:chunk_0012","session_date":"2025-12-19","session_id":"NfrdKX5NBQc","session_part":"上午","start_seconds":3540,"summary":"本段文字討論關於京華城案中，都發局長黃局長涉嫌在都市計畫審議過程中，無視公務員及專家學者的釋法疑慮，在議員壓力下強行將不符合都更要件的計畫送交公展，並質疑其利用「類推適用」或「參考」都更容積獎勵之手段，規避法律限制以圖利京華城，涉嫌違反公平性與對價性審查原則。","video_id":"NfrdKX5NBQc","raw_text_key":"text/NfrdKX5NBQc/raw/chunk_0012.txt","cleaned_text_key":"text/NfrdKX5NBQc/cleaned/chunk_0012.txt","_links":{"self":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/NfrdKX5NBQc:chunk_0012","read":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/NfrdKX5NBQc:chunk_0012/read","raw":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/NfrdKX5NBQc:chunk_0012/raw","cleaned":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/NfrdKX5NBQc:chunk_0012/cleaned","session":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/sessions/NfrdKX5NBQc","case":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/cases/113年度金訴字第51號"}}