{"case_id":"113年度金訴字第51號","case_number":"113年度金訴字第51號","chunk_filename":"chunk_0019.txt","chunk_index":19,"documents_referenced":["109年2月18日會見紀錄","109年2月21日晨會紀錄","109年3月10日便當會紀錄","109年4月1日之通聯簡訊","113年9月27日及113年10月11日之訊問錄音錄影","起訴書"],"end_seconds":5905,"keywords":["合意","對價關係","政治獻金","行賄","訊問施壓","證據不足"],"legal_issues":["行賄罪之主觀合意與對價關係之認定","訊問過程是否涉及強迫、施壓或違法誘導供述","證據之充足性（指控行賄之證據是否僅為揣測）"],"legal_issues_raw":["訊問過程是否涉及強迫、施壓或違法誘導供述","行賄罪之主觀合意與對價關係之認定","證據之充足性（指控行賄之證據是否僅為揣測）"],"participants":["審判長","提及：柯文哲、沈清津","檢察官","證人","辯護人"],"participants_raw":["辯護人","審判長","檢察官（提及：郭堅宇、林俊廷、廖玉軍）","被告（提及：柯文哲、沈清津）","證人（提及：豬牙虎、彭振聲、黃景茂）"],"phase":"言詞辯論","record_type":"segment","segment_id":"X9M3axM1LIU:chunk_0019","session_date":"2025-12-18","session_id":"X9M3axM1LIU","session_part":"上午","start_seconds":5605,"summary":"辯護人針對檢察官在訊問過程中的強壓手段、對證人（如豬牙虎）的斥責及誘導供述提出質疑，並主張檢方關於沈清津、柯文哲有行賄合意之主張缺乏證據，僅憑揣測及不相關的會議紀錄（如晨會、便當會）來補強，試圖證明被告並無行賄之意圖與對價關係。","video_id":"X9M3axM1LIU","raw_text_key":"text/X9M3axM1LIU/raw/chunk_0019.txt","cleaned_text_key":"text/X9M3axM1LIU/cleaned/chunk_0019.txt","_links":{"self":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/X9M3axM1LIU:chunk_0019","read":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/X9M3axM1LIU:chunk_0019/read","raw":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/X9M3axM1LIU:chunk_0019/raw","cleaned":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/segments/X9M3axM1LIU:chunk_0019/cleaned","session":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/sessions/X9M3axM1LIU","case":"https://5pwpri46fd.execute-api.ap-east-2.amazonaws.com/cases/113年度金訴字第51號"}}